Category: Uncategorized

  • The Uncomfortable Truth About ACL Rehabilitation

    There is no magic program. There are no guarantees. And the reality of rehabilitation is rarely what you imagine.

    It has taken me six years to develop an ACL rehabilitation framework that I’m genuinely happy with.

    I’ll probably change parts of it again within the next few months.

    It started with a frustration.

    My rehabilitation framework didn’t have a movement pathway for what is, in most cases, a movement-related injury.

    Most ACL injuries occur without contact, during deceleration, landing or changing direction.

    Yet I wasn’t doing enough to address those movements in rehabilitation.

    And being honest, I didn’t have the skill set back then.

    So why did it take six years?

    We have more information than ever. Research, podcasts, social media and access to exceptional practitioners doing extraordinary work.

    I’ve learned a tremendous amount from them.

    I’ve also learned a tremendous amount from more than 20 years of clinical experience.

    But the biggest challenge has been working out what is actually achievable with the athletes I treat, within the limitations of the environment I work in.

    I’ve learned that the perfect rehabilitation program isn’t necessarily the right program for most people.

    The problem with exceptional results

    Some industry leaders report extraordinary rehabilitation outcomes and remarkably low reinjury rates.

    But look at the populations behind those results.

    Elite athletes. Residential rehabilitation programs. Specialist programs that attract highly motivated athletes willing to commit significant time, effort and financial resources to their recovery.

    These athletes often have years of structured training behind them.

    That matters.

    I’m not questioning the quality of these programs. Some are exceptional.

    I’ve tried to replicate aspects of them.

    But trying to replicate that level of detail with athletes who have limited time, resources or training experience can become counterproductive.

    We risk overwhelming the athlete and losing sight of the key priorities that actually need to be addressed.

    The perfect program isn’t perfect if the athlete cannot complete it.

    The athletes I actually treat

    I work with almost anyone who walks through the door.

    Their training histories, physical abilities, movement competency and previous injuries vary enormously.

    Some have never lifted meaningful weights.

    Let’s be honest, some hate the gym!

    Some have never received movement coaching.

    Some have spent months, sometimes years, in rehabilitation elsewhere and still don’t appear or feel ready to return to sport.

    For some of these athletes, reaching commonly proposed strength, jump and movement benchmarks could take years of dedicated training, even without an ACL injury.

    That doesn’t mean we should abandon those standards.

    But we cannot ignore the athlete’s starting point. Otherwise, our rehabilitation sessions and progressions risk becoming ineffective.

    And then there’s everything outside the clinic.

    Jobs. Families. Travel. Financial pressures. Long days on their feet. Missed appointments. Inconsistent training.

    Some athletes simply don’t have the confidence or knowledge to progress their training away from the clinic.

    Others struggle to commit to rehabilitation or disappear before completing it.

    I have considerable sympathy for them.

    But the physical demands of their sport don’t disappear because life gets in the way.

    The standard required to perform doesn’t change. The opportunity to reach it does.

    I believe this gap between what rehabilitation demands and what athletes can realistically complete contributes to the continuing problem of ACL reinjury.

    Does the physical therapist still matter?

    Enormously.

    ACL reinjury rates remain concerning. Better rehabilitation will reduce that risk.

    Our clinic regularly sees athletes who started their rehabilitation elsewhere and are unhappy with their progress.

    I see missed opportunities. Gaps in strength development. Limited movement preparation.

    Most commonly, I see athletes who have progressed through rehabilitation without establishing what I consider the basics: the ABCs of rehabilitation.

    But I’m not pretending I always get everything right either.

    I rarely finish a rehabilitation program feeling I’ve delivered the perfect process.

    Sometimes that’s my mindset.

    Sometimes I genuinely could have done better.

    Because I’m trying to manage a lot.

    Knee symptoms. Strength. Objective testing. Plyometrics. Movement development. Return-to-sport preparation.

    And with limited time, I know there are consultations where one or several of those areas don’t receive the attention they deserve.

    That’s the reality of clinical practice.

    There are opportunities to do better. But for many athletes, time and cost remain significant limitations.

    The physical therapist matters. The framework matters. And the willingness to keep improving matters.

    What I can actually offer

    I’ve spent six years building a framework designed to make every stage of rehabilitation count.

    Managing the acute knee.

    Developing meaningful strength.

    Progressive plyometrics.

    And movement.

    I strongly believe that becoming an effective and efficient mover is fundamental to successful rehabilitation.

    My framework is supported by force plates, dynamometry and a comprehensive battery of objective performance tests.

    But the technology is only part of it.

    It takes an experienced clinical eye to interpret the results and understand how an athlete moves.

    Not just whether two limbs are symmetrical, but whether an athlete has developed sufficient strength, reactive capacity and movement competency.

    Not just how far or high someone jumps.

    How they move.

    How they absorb force.

    How they compensate.

    How they respond when the demands increase.

    I believe strongly in the quality of this process and the attention I give to each element of rehabilitation.

    I also believe that level of detail is not consistently available across everyday ACL rehabilitation.

    But I don’t run a residential rehabilitation facility.

    I can’t supervise every strength session, every field progression or every sporting exposure.

    I have to make the most of the time I have, prepare athletes as thoroughly as possible and give them the tools to continue independently.

    My responsibility is to deliver the best rehabilitation possible within the circumstances of the athlete in front of me.

    Not an idealized athlete with unlimited time and resources.

    There is no magic pill

    I cannot guarantee that every athlete will complete rehabilitation.

    I cannot guarantee adherence.

    And I cannot manufacture years of strength training and movement experience in a few months.

    Not everyone will reach the highest proposed ACL rehabilitation benchmarks within a typical rehabilitation timeframe.

    Sometimes that means acknowledging that their circumstances make the ideal rehabilitation process impossible.

    Good ACL rehabilitation matters enormously. But the program is only part of the outcome.

    The athlete matters.

    Their starting point matters.

    Their circumstances matter.

    And sometimes, despite everyone’s best efforts, the outcome won’t be what we hoped.

    That’s not a reason to lower our standards. It’s a reason to be honest about what rehabilitation can, and cannot, promise.

  • Where Does ACL Rehab Go Wrong?

    ACL rehab rarely goes wrong because of one major mistake. More often, small things are missed at different stages of the process, and those misses become more important as the demands increase.

    A knee that never truly settles. Quadriceps function that never fully returns. Physical development that doesn’t progress far enough. Movement compensations that aren’t identified. Testing that becomes a box-ticking exercise rather than something that guides rehabilitation.

    By the time an athlete is trying to run, jump, cut and return to sport, those earlier gaps can become much harder to ignore.

    Sometimes ACL rehab goes wrong at the beginning

    Some of the problems we see later in ACL rehabilitation started much earlier.

    An athlete may progress through the stages of rehab without ever fully restoring the basics: a quiet knee, full motion and good quadriceps function.

    Months later, they may be running, jumping and lifting, but still dealing with recurrent swelling, an extension deficit or a quadriceps that has never properly recovered.

    Moving forward in rehab doesn’t necessarily mean the early problems have been resolved.

    Sometimes progressing an athlete means first identifying what was missed.

    Strength is essential. But it isn’t the end point.

    Restoring quadriceps and lower-limb strength is fundamental after ACL reconstruction.

    But eventually the athlete needs more than strength alone.

    Sport requires the ability to produce force quickly, absorb force, express power, repeat high-intensity efforts and tolerate increasingly demanding athletic tasks.

    Rehabilitation therefore needs to evolve from restoring strength toward developing the broader physical qualities required for sport.

    The question changes from “Is this athlete getting stronger?” to:

    “Are we preparing this athlete for what their sport actually requires?”

    Movement needs to be coached

    Athletes don’t return to a collection of gym exercises.

    They return to accelerating, decelerating, landing, cutting, reacting and making decisions at speed.

    Movement coaching is a skill in itself.

    Analyzing how an athlete lands, brakes or changes direction, and knowing how to progressively coach those qualities, requires experience and deliberate practice.

    We shouldn’t assume movement quality automatically returns because an athlete gets stronger or starts running again.

    If we want athletes to return to movement, we have to train movement.

    A test score doesn’t tell us everything

    Objective testing is an important part of ACL rehabilitation. Strength, jump and performance measures can reveal deficits that aren’t obvious from observation alone.

    But numbers need interpretation.

    A test result tells us what an athlete achieved. How they achieved it matters too.

    The strategies and compensations used to complete a task can reveal things that a score alone may miss.

    This is also why a single number such as 90% limb symmetry shouldn’t be viewed as the destination. Symmetry can be useful, but it doesn’t necessarily tell us whether both limbs are strong enough, how the athlete produced the result or whether they’re prepared for their sport.

    Testing should ultimately answer a more useful question:

    What does this tell us about what the athlete needs next?

    Passing return-to-sport testing isn’t the finish line

    Return-to-sport testing has helped move ACL rehabilitation beyond simply waiting a certain number of months after surgery.

    But passing a battery shouldn’t become the end goal either.

    An athlete can perform well in controlled testing and still have had very little exposure to speed, repeated efforts, reactive movement, fatigue or the unpredictability of sport.

    They may also test well physically but still not feel ready to return.

    Testing should guide the rehabilitation process, not replace it.

    Small misses become bigger as the demands increase

    Early in rehabilitation, a deficit can be relatively easy to compensate for.

    Later, the demands expose it.

    Walking becomes running.
    Strength becomes power.
    Controlled jumping becomes reactive jumping.
    Planned movement becomes unpredictable movement.
    Rehabilitation becomes sport.

    This is why ACL rehabilitation needs to keep evolving.

    What matters at three months isn’t necessarily what matters at nine months.

    Good ACL rehab progresses with the athlete

    There isn’t one perfect ACL exercise, one perfect testing battery or one milestone that tells us rehabilitation has been successful.

    Early on, the priority may be restoring a quiet, mobile knee and recovering quadriceps function.

    Then comes developing strength and the physical qualities required for sport.

    Movement becomes faster and more complex. Testing helps identify what is improving and what still needs attention. Exposure progressively begins to resemble the demands the athlete is returning to.

    At every stage, the question should be:

    What does this athlete need next?

    ACL rehabilitation should restore the athlete, not just the knee.

    The goal isn’t simply to rehabilitate a reconstructed ACL.

    It’s to rebuild the athlete around it.


    Not sure where your ACL rehab is getting stuck?

    Whether you’re early in rehabilitation or approaching return to sport, an objective assessment can help identify what’s progressing well, what may have been missed and what should come next.

    KICK Performance Therapy provides ACL rehabilitation and return-to-sport assessment in Portland, Oregon, with online ACL assessment available for athletes further afield.

  • Why Does My ACL Knee Still Feel Weak Even Though My Strength Tests Look Good?

    Your strength numbers look good. Your side-to-side symmetry may even be above 90%. So why does the reconstructed leg still feel weak?

    This is a common experience after ACL reconstruction. The answer is often not that the strength test is wrong. It is that “strength” is a much bigger quality than the number produced during one controlled test.

    A maximal isometric or slow strength test tells us something important: how much force you can produce under those particular conditions. Sport asks whether you can access, absorb and repeat force quickly — while moving, reacting and becoming fatigued.

    A strong test does not always mean a fully restored quadriceps

    One of the first things I look at is whether the strength result fits the rest of the athlete.

    An athlete can produce a surprisingly good peak isometric force while the reconstructed-side quadriceps still looks visibly smaller. A single maximal value does not directly tell us that muscle size, architecture, endurance and the ability to express force across different speeds and joint positions have all returned.

    That distinction matters. Quadriceps atrophy is common after ACL reconstruction, and muscle size is related to strength — but the relationship is not perfect. Neural factors, testing position, familiarization and an athlete’s ability to recruit the available muscle can all influence a maximal test.

    PEAK FORCE IS IMPORTANT. IT IS NOT THE WHOLE STORY.

    A good maximal strength score does not automatically mean the limb has recovered the muscle capacity, speed of force production, braking ability and repeatability needed for sport.

    The “skinny but strong” quadriceps

    Sometimes an athlete reaches a respectable strength number while the quadriceps still appears noticeably underdeveloped compared with the other side. I would not ignore that simply because the dynamometer says the athlete is strong.

    Think of the maximal test as one expression of the system. The athlete may be very good at recruiting what they have for a brief effort, but reduced muscle mass may become more relevant when we ask the limb to produce high forces repeatedly, work through different joint angles, absorb eccentric load or maintain performance as fatigue develops.

    This is one reason I combine strength testing with the clinical picture: muscle development, training history, movement, jumping and the athlete’s response to progressively harder tasks.

    How quickly can you use your strength?

    Maximal force and rapid force production are not the same thing.

    Rate of force development describes how rapidly force rises. That matters in sport because many actions happen in a fraction of the time available during a maximal strength test. Research after ACL reconstruction has demonstrated that athletes can recover maximal voluntary strength while deficits in rapid force production remain.

    This can help explain why an athlete feels strong in the gym but less convincing when sprinting, jumping, changing direction or reacting quickly.

    Can you absorb force as well as produce it?

    Sport is not only about pushing. It is also about braking.

    Landing, decelerating and changing direction require the lower limb to accept and control substantial forces. An athlete may demonstrate good concentric or isometric strength yet still avoid loading the reconstructed knee during these tasks.

    That is why I am interested in eccentric capacity and movement strategy. Does the athlete actually use the knee when absorbing force, or do they find a way to shift demand toward the hip, ankle, trunk or opposite limb?

    Relative strength matters too

    Side-to-side symmetry tells us how similar the limbs are. It does not necessarily tell us whether either limb is strong enough for the athlete’s body mass and sporting demands.

    An athlete can be symmetrically weak. Conversely, a reconstructed limb can remain somewhat asymmetrical while both limbs have developed substantial absolute capacity. This is why I prefer to interpret symmetry alongside absolute and, where appropriate, bodyweight-relative strength rather than using one percentage in isolation.

    What happens after the first repetition?

    Many strength tests capture a short maximal effort. Sport repeatedly asks for force.

    If the reconstructed limb loses output more rapidly, movement quality changes under fatigue or the athlete progressively unloads the knee, a single peak value may never reveal the problem. Capacity across repeated jumps, repeated contacts, running and progressively demanding training can therefore provide information that a one-off maximal test cannot.

    Sometimes the weakness you feel is a movement problem

    Athletes do not experience their knee as a dynamometer number. They experience it while moving.

    If you hesitate when loading the reconstructed side, shorten ground contact differently, reduce knee contribution during a jump or rely more heavily on another joint, the limb may feel weak even when maximal strength is respectable.

    That sensation can be useful information. Rather than dismissing it because the strength test “passed,” I want to understand where the mismatch appears and what changes when the task becomes faster, more reactive or more sport-like.

    So what should we test when strength looks good but the leg doesn’t feel right?

    • Maximal strength: confirm that the apparent strength recovery is real and consider absolute and relative values, not symmetry alone.
    • Muscle development: consider whether visible or measured quadriceps atrophy remains relevant to the athlete’s overall capacity.
    • Rapid force production: assess whether force can be generated quickly rather than only maximally.
    • Explosive and reactive performance: examine jumping and shorter ground-contact tasks where appropriate.
    • Eccentric and braking capacity: look at how the athlete absorbs force during landing and deceleration.
    • Movement strategy: assess whether performance is being achieved through compensations.
    • Repeatability and fatigue: determine whether quality and output persist as demands accumulate.
    • Sport exposure: establish whether the athlete has actually had enough progressive high-speed and sport-specific work to translate gym capacity into performance.

    I have core tests that I use regularly, but I also draw from a wider testing toolbox depending on the athlete, their injury history, sport and what I am seeing during rehabilitation. The goal is not to collect more numbers for the sake of it. It is to identify the quality that is still limiting the athlete.

    Strength can explain a lot — but it cannot explain everything

    I strongly believe in strength testing. When strength is genuinely deficient, improving it often has a remarkable effect on movement, confidence and performance.

    But when an athlete tells me, “My strength tests are good, but the leg still doesn’t feel right,” I don’t think the conversation should end there.

    That is often the point at which we need to ask a better question: what can this athlete do with the strength they have?

    MEASURE → MOVE → PERFORM

    DON’T STOP TESTING WHEN THE STRENGTH NUMBER LOOKS GOOD.

    If your reconstructed leg still feels weak or different despite good strength scores, a broader assessment can help identify whether the missing piece is rapid force production, reactive ability, braking capacity, movement strategy, fatigue or sport exposure.

    Key research

    • Angelozzi M, et al. Rate of force development as an adjunctive outcome measure for return-to-sport decisions after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2012.
    • Thomas AC, Wojtys EM, Brandon C, Palmieri-Smith RM. Muscle atrophy contributes to quadriceps weakness after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. J Sci Med Sport. 2016.
    • Kotsifaki A, et al. Research demonstrating that symmetrical hop distance can mask persistent asymmetries in knee function after ACL reconstruction.
    • Wellsandt E, Failla MJ, Snyder-Mackler L. Limb Symmetry Indexes Can Overestimate Knee Function After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2017.
  • When Can I Start Running After ACL Reconstruction?

    “When can I start running?” is one of the most common questions after ACL reconstruction. My answer is usually another question: what kind of running are we trying to return you to?

    For someone whose goal is recreational distance running, rebuilding steady running volume may be exactly the right progression. For an athlete returning to soccer, basketball, ultimate or another high-speed multidirectional sport, however, a long period of slow jogging should not automatically become the centerpiece of mid-stage rehabilitation.

    Running is an important milestone. But the goal is not simply to prove that you can jog. The goal is to progressively prepare you for the forces, speeds, decisions and repeated high-intensity actions your sport actually requires.

    Return to running should be criteria-based, not calendar-based

    Time since surgery matters because healing biology matters. But reaching a particular postoperative week does not automatically mean the knee is ready to run.

    Current clinical guidance recommends combining time with clinical and functional criteria. Suggested markers include full knee extension, close to full flexion, little or no swelling, sufficient quadriceps strength and the ability to tolerate repeated single-leg hopping without pain.

    I use core markers like these, but I do not believe one fixed battery suits every athlete. I also draw from a wider range of tests depending on the athlete’s history, sport, graft, current deficits and what I am seeing throughout rehabilitation.

    Before running, I want to see the basics

    Running should not become a way of bypassing unfinished rehabilitation.

    Before progressing, I want confidence that the knee is clinically settled and that the athlete has developed enough strength, control and elastic capacity for the next demand. That can include knee range and swelling, quadriceps and lower-limb strength, calf capacity, controlled single-leg loading, jumping and landing preparation, repeated low-level reactive contacts and movement quality.

    The exact markers change with the individual. The important principle is that the athlete earns progression by demonstrating capacity rather than simply reaching a date on the calendar.

    RUNNING IS A MILESTONE. IT IS NOT THE DESTINATION.

    For a field or court athlete, the bigger question is whether rehabilitation is progressively preparing you to accelerate, decelerate, sprint, cut, react and repeat those actions.

    Jogging and returning to athletic movement are not the same progression

    I have no objection to steady jogging when it serves the athlete’s goals. If running itself is your sport or something you enjoy, rebuilding it progressively makes sense.

    For a multidirectional athlete, though, I often prefer to place greater emphasis on drill-based running and movement progressions. These allow us to deconstruct athletic actions and progressively expose the athlete to positions, rhythms and forces that will later underpin faster sport.

    Rather than accumulating large amounts of slow running simply because it is easy to prescribe, we can use appropriate drills to develop running mechanics, stiffness and elastic qualities, acceleration positions, force application and eventually greater speed.

    This does not mean going from rehabilitation straight into maximal sprinting. It means building a deliberate bridge from controlled movement to higher-intensity movement.

    Why I don’t want jogging to dominate the middle of rehab

    A long, generic return-to-run progression can add a substantial amount of training volume. For some athletes that volume is useful. For others it competes with the qualities they most need to restore: strength, power, reactive ability, speed and high-quality athletic movement.

    If every week becomes longer bouts of low-intensity running on top of gym work and rehabilitation, the athlete can simply become tired without becoming meaningfully better prepared for the actions associated with their sport.

    Most non-contact ACL injuries are not sustained during comfortable straight-line jogging. They are more commonly associated with demanding actions such as rapid deceleration, change of direction or landing. That does not make jogging bad. It means jogging alone provides limited preparation for the situations we ultimately care about.

    Can drill-based movement begin before continuous running?

    In many athletes, elements of athletic movement can be introduced before they are completing meaningful volumes of continuous running — provided the task is appropriate for their stage of healing and current capacity.

    Early work may be relatively simple: athletic postures, marching and rhythm drills, controlled foot contacts, low-level landing tasks and rehearsed movement patterns. As the athlete demonstrates success, those tasks can progress in speed, amplitude, force and complexity.

    This creates a continuum rather than a sudden transition from “rehab exercises” to “sports training.”

    The coach’s eye still matters

    Objective testing gives us information that observation alone cannot. But numbers do not tell the whole story.

    I also want to see how the athlete moves. Are they accepting load through the reconstructed limb? Do they look comfortable during repeated contacts? Are they creating unnecessary compensations? Does movement deteriorate when speed increases? Can they reproduce a task consistently rather than simply complete one good repetition?

    The combination of objective testing, clinical response and experienced movement observation is more useful to me than a single “return-to-run test.”

    Physical readiness is only part of readiness

    The first running and jumping progressions can also feel psychologically significant after ACL reconstruction. Some athletes are eager to move faster; others remain hesitant despite good physical testing.

    That response matters. Progression should create successful exposures that build trust in the limb rather than forcing an athlete through a stage simply because the protocol says it is time.

    So when can you start running?

    There is no single number that answers that question for everyone. A useful decision considers healing time, symptoms, swelling and range of motion alongside objective strength, jumping and reactive capacity, movement quality and psychological readiness.

    And for athletes returning to high-speed sport, I would broaden the question:

    When are you ready to start rebuilding athletic movement — and what progression will best prepare you for the sport you actually want to return to?

    That is a much more useful rehabilitation question than simply asking when you are allowed to jog.

    MEASURE → MOVE → PERFORM

    DON’T JUST RETURN TO RUNNING. BUILD TOWARD THE WAY YOUR SPORT MOVES.

    If you are unsure whether you are ready to begin running or want a progression that better reflects the demands of your sport, an ACL assessment can help identify the right next step.

    Key research

    • Aspetar. Clinical practice guideline on rehabilitation after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Br J Sports Med. 2023.
    • Rambaud AJM, Ardern CL, Thoreux P, Regnaux JP, Edouard P. Criteria for return to running after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a scoping review. Br J Sports Med. 2018.
    • Burgi CR, et al. Which criteria are used to clear patients to return to sport after primary ACL reconstruction? A scoping review. Br J Sports Med. 2019.
  • Cleared After ACL Surgery But Still Don’t Feel Ready to Return to Sport?

    Being cleared after ACL reconstruction and feeling ready to return to sport are not always the same thing.

    You may have restored your range of motion. Your strength numbers may look good. You may have passed hop tests and reached the expected stage of rehabilitation. Yet when you imagine sprinting, cutting, reacting to another player or returning to competition, something still doesn’t feel right.

    That feeling deserves attention. Return to sport is physical, psychological and highly individual — and many of the qualities that make an athlete feel capable again should be developed long before the final return-to-sport test.

    Cleared does not always mean ready

    Return-to-sport clearance is an important milestone, but it cannot perfectly reproduce the demands of sport. Research consistently shows that athletes can still demonstrate physical deficits around the time they are cleared, while psychological readiness is also strongly associated with whether athletes actually return.

    This helps explain why an athlete can look good on paper but still feel a significant gap between rehabilitation and competition.

    STRONG ENOUGH FOR A TEST IS NOT AUTOMATICALLY READY FOR SPORT.

    Sport asks you to produce force quickly, absorb it, react, make decisions, repeat high-intensity actions and trust the reconstructed limb — often while fatigued and under pressure.

    Strength matters — but sport asks you to express it

    I strongly believe in strength testing after ACL reconstruction. If the quadriceps, hamstrings or wider lower limb remain significantly under-strength, that can explain many of the compensations and limitations an athlete experiences.

    But maximal strength is one physical quality. An athlete may be strong in a controlled test and still lack explosive strength, rate of force development, eccentric braking capacity or reactive strength. They may be able to produce force, but not yet access and organize it at the speed their sport demands.

    That is why strength should be considered a foundation rather than the final destination.

    These qualities can be developed much earlier

    Athletic rehabilitation should not suddenly begin when an athlete is almost ready to return.

    From earlier stages of ACL rehabilitation, we can begin rebuilding the qualities that later make sport feel familiar: athletic positions, controlled movement strategies, confidence accepting load through the reconstructed limb and progressively faster force production.

    As strength and healing progress, those foundations can evolve into jumping, landing, acceleration, deceleration, multidirectional movement and eventually reactive, sport-relevant tasks. The intensity changes throughout rehabilitation, but the goal of preparing an athlete to move like an athlete can be present from much earlier.

    Sport demands more than physical capacity

    Sport requires more than strength, power and movement capacity. Athletes also have to process information, make decisions and coordinate an appropriate movement response — often at speed and without time to consciously think about the knee.

    These demands are difficult to reproduce with predictable rehabilitation exercises alone. An athlete may perform extremely well when they know exactly what movement is coming next, yet feel very different when they have to respond to another player, a ball, changing space or an unexpected cue.

    That is one reason rehabilitation can progress beyond predictable drills. As appropriate, tasks can incorporate external cues, decision-making, reaction, visual information, opponents or teammates, dual-task demands and increasingly unpredictable movement. The aim is not simply to make exercises complicated. It is to reconnect physical capacity with the perception-action demands of sport.

    The mental side of returning can feel overwhelming

    An athlete can pass every physical test placed in front of them and still not feel psychologically ready.

    Fear of reinjury, hesitation, reduced confidence and uncertainty about whether the knee will cope are common after ACL reconstruction. Research shows that psychological readiness is meaningfully associated with return to sport, even when conventional measures of knee function are similar.

    This should not be dismissed as something the athlete simply needs to “get over.” It should be explored. What exactly feels threatening? Is it contact? Cutting off the reconstructed side? Landing in traffic? An unpredictable opponent? Fatigue? Returning to the environment in which the injury occurred?

    Those answers can help shape rehabilitation. Appropriate graded exposure can allow an athlete to experience successful movement at progressively greater speed, complexity and uncertainty. In some cases, psychological support beyond physical therapy may also be valuable.

    Confidence is difficult to test into existence

    Confidence often grows through evidence.

    Evidence that the leg is strong. Evidence that you can land and absorb force. Evidence that you can sprint. Evidence that you can cut. Evidence that you can react without protecting the knee. And, importantly, evidence accumulated across weeks of progressively harder training rather than one successful testing session.

    This is where return-to-sport testing and return-to-sport preparation need to work together. Testing can identify what is missing. Training gives the athlete the exposure to change it. Reassessment tells us whether that change persists as the task becomes faster and less predictable.

    If you’ve been cleared but don’t feel ready, what should you look at?

    • Absolute strength and symmetry: are you genuinely strong enough, or simply similar from side to side?
    • Explosive and reactive qualities: can you produce, absorb and reproduce force quickly?
    • Movement strategy: are you confidently using the reconstructed limb or finding subtle ways around it?
    • Conditioning: can you maintain movement quality and decision-making as fatigue increases?
    • Athletic exposure: have you built enough sprinting, deceleration, cutting, jumping and sport-specific training over time?
    • Neurocognitive demands: have you progressed beyond rehearsed tasks into reacting, deciding and moving in response to external information?
    • Psychological readiness: what situations still create hesitation or fear, and have they been progressively addressed?

    The answer will not be identical for every athlete. That is why I prefer to use testing as part of an ongoing process rather than a universal pass/fail checklist.

    MEASURE → MOVE → PERFORM

    YOU DON’T HAVE TO WAIT UNTIL THE END OF REHAB TO START PREPARING FOR SPORT.

    If you’ve been cleared after ACL reconstruction but still don’t feel ready — or you want to address these qualities before reaching that point — a focused assessment can help identify what is missing and build the next stage around you and your sport.

    Key research

    • Webster KE, Hewett TE. What is the Evidence for and Validity of Return-to-Sport Testing after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Surgery? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Sports Med. 2019.
    • Webster KE, Feller JA. Research examining psychological readiness and the ACL Return to Sport after Injury (ACL-RSI) scale.
    • Piussi R, et al. Research examining knee confidence, fear of movement and psychological readiness following ACL reconstruction.
    • Grooms DR, et al. Research examining neuroplasticity and sensorimotor control following ACL injury and reconstruction.